Someone on your team gets an email saying their Microsoft password expires today. The link opens a sign-in page that matches the real one pixel for pixel. They type their password. A six-digit code arrives on their phone, and they type that too, because the page asked for it.
That second step was supposed to be the safety net. On a fake page, it is just one more thing to type.
Codes protect you until someone asks for them
If your business uses multi-factor authentication (MFA, a second proof of identity on top of the password), that second proof is usually a code by text or from an app. It works well against the most common attack: a criminal holding a stolen list of passwords. The password alone gets them nowhere.
A live fake page is different. Whatever your employee types, the attacker passes straight to the real site within seconds, code included. The real site sees a correct password and a correct code, and it lets them in.
From there they are reading the mailbox, watching invoices go out, and waiting for the right moment to change a bank account number on one of them.
A passkey checks the address before it answers
A passkey replaces the password and the code with a key stored on a device. The website keeps only a matching public half, which is useless on its own.
When you sign in, the site sends a one-time challenge, and your device signs it with the key. Think of it as a signature rather than a secret: someone can watch you sign a document and still be unable to forge your signature.
Here is the part that matters. Each passkey is tied to the exact web address it was created for. A fake page at a look-alike address asks the device to sign, and the device has no key for that address. The employee has nothing to type, so there is nothing to hand over, however convincing the page is.
People skip the strongest option because it used to be a chore
Security that gets used is security that is easy. People want to be protected; they put off anything that feels like a project.
The strongest version of a passkey lives on a hardware security key, a small physical key that fits on a keyring. Until recently, using one with an Android phone meant cables, adapters or awkward workarounds, so most people never got past setup.
That has changed. Android phones running version 9 or newer now accept a security key with a tap, over NFC (the same short-range connection used for contactless payments). It works within a few centimeters, so the key has to be practically touching the phone.
Who should carry a key
For most staff, passkeys stored on their phone or in a password manager are a big step up and enough.
A hardware key earns its place for a few specific people: the owner, whoever pays bills or approves transfers, and whoever runs Microsoft 365 for everyone else. Their key lives on their keyring, apart from their phone, so their sign-in stays with them when a phone goes missing. For the people who run Microsoft 365, the business can require the key to sign in rather than just offering it.
Three questions worth answering this week
- Which three to five people in your business can approve a payment, change bank details, or reset other people’s accounts?
- When those people sign in to Microsoft 365 and your bank, what do they type?
- If one of them typed it into a perfect copy of that sign-in page tomorrow morning, what could the attacker do before anyone noticed?
If the answer to the second question is a password and a code, the third question has a dollar figure attached: whatever the next invoice they redirect happens to be worth. A key that only answers the real address takes that figure off the table for the people who can move your money.
👉 New to Borked PC? Start by filling out our quick Right Fit Questionnaire to see if Borked PC could be the right IT and Cybersecurity Partner for you.
📞 Or schedule a free 15-minute call at a time that works for you: Book a call
Prefer to talk now? Give us a call at (610) 599-6195.
